BIBLE TRUTH vs CULTURAL PERSPECTIVE
Sunday School Class
Jerrold Wynia
The Disruption of Creation Order
(Oct 11)
What is Creation Order?
- Genesis 1:31-2:1 – “God saw all that He had made, and it was
very good. And there was evening, and there was morning – the sixth day.
Thus the heavens and the earth were completed in all their vast array.” - Order
that God established in His work of Creation
◦
In God’s created world there was no sin, hence
no chaos, only order
◦
With the fall and the entrance of sin, all of
creation was infected, chaos was introduced
◦
Creation order establishes the way that God
intended in the midst of the chaos, pointing to Him as the creator
◦
After the fall, God reasserted creation order
for our protection
- Another
term could be natural law or ontology
◦
The way things are, the reality of things.
◦
Robert P.
George (Princeton Legal Scholar and Political Philosopher: “It is
obligatory on everyone. It is not a ritual or set of rules… This is
fundamentally about what it right and wrong, good
and bad, just and unjust insofar as that is knowable, at least in principle by
our human reason or to quote St. Paul insofar as it is a part of the law
written on the hearts of all of us, even the Gentiles… We as Christians
believe that the intellect has been darkened by sin. It’s not just that the
will has been weakened, but the intellect has been darkened, and so we’re not
going to know it perfectly and all of us will err and all of us will go wrong
and all of us will sin.”
◦
Romans 2:14-15 – “Indeed, when Gentiles, who
do not have the law, do by nature things required by the law, they are a law
for themselves, even though they do not have the law, since they show that the
requirements of the law are written on their hearts, their consciences also
bearing witness, and their thoughts now accusing, now even defending them.”
- Think
of the role of government and what life would be like without government
◦
To maintain order
◦
Life under a good government (USA) vs life under
a bad government (Haiti)
History of the Creation Order
- Martin
Luther – the exact term translated as “orders of creation” - John
Calvin – it was God’s revelation in nature of things that are knowable to
all based upon the Imago Dei inferences drawn.
◦
The Imago Dei means “image of God”, referring to
our belief that man is created in the likeness of God as revealed to us in
Genesis 1:27
▪
“So God created man in His own image, in the
image of God He created him; male and female He created them.”
◦
This is more of a general revelation of God
through His creation, i.e. marriage
◦
The there is Special revelation of God in
scripture to make clear how to order marriage
What are examples of creation order?
- Humans
were created as male and female
◦
Genesis 1:27
◦
a man claiming to be a woman is a direct
subversion
- Marriage
between man and woman
◦
Genesis 2:24 – “For this reason a man will
leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and they will become one
flesh.”
- Sex
only within a marriage context, actually God even speaks to the wandering
eyes of men, whether it be at the beach or on a screen.
◦
Matthew 5:27-28 – “You have heard that it was
said, ‘Do not commit adultery.’ But I tell you that anyone who looks at a woman
lustfully has already committed adultery with her is his heart.”
◦
You do not need to be married to commit
adultery.
- Sanctity
of Life – Fearfully and wonderfully made
◦
Jeremiah 1:5
◦
Psalm 139:13-16
- Children
born out of marriage union
◦
Genesis 1:28 – “God blessed them and said to
them, ‘Be fruitful and increase in number; fill the earth and subdue it…”
Where do we see creation order being subverted?
- The
age of “consent” and the hookup culture - Living
together before marriage - Abortion
- The
push of the LGBTQ+ agenda - Transgenderism
- Men
competing in women’s sports - Same-sex
marriage - Polyamory
- Definition
of Truth – everyone is doing what is right in their own eyes, just like
the Israelite’s during the time of the Judges. - What
about a procedure like IVF?
What is IVF?
- In
Vitro Fertilization
◦
Assisted reproductive technology
◦
When first it came to the attention of the
public it was called “test tube babies”
▪
3 doctors in Great Britain developed the
procedure and were first successful in 1977
▪
Louise Brown was born July 25, 1978.
▪
Conception actually took place in a petri dish
◦
The sperm of a male is introduces to the egg of
a female in a laboratory setting. Fertilization takes place and the development
of a human being begins with the formation of a human embryo
◦
Multiple human embryos are created during the
process due to the high cost
◦
A healthy embryo is then placed in the uterus of
a woman.
What should be our Foundation concerning human life?
- The
EFCA has not issued a statement on this, hence we look to the Southern
Baptist Convention as they have
addressed it
◦
The SBC is closely aligned in beliefs with the
EFCA, hence we can find value from their studies and subsequent statements
- The
SBC published a document titled ‘On
the Ethical Realities of Reproductive Technologies and the Dignity of the
Human Embryo’ in 2024. What follows are some key foundational truths..
◦
Every human being is made in God’s image
(Genesis 1:27-28) and is thus to be respected and protected from the moment of
fertilization until natural death, without regard to developmental stage or
location.
◦
Human beings possess an inherent right to life
and the opportunity to reach their full developmental maturity (Exodus 20:13)
◦
Infertility affects many married couples who
have the good and godly desire to bring children into the world.
◦
Couples who experience the searing pain of
infertility can turn to God, look to Scripture for numerous examples of
infertility, and know that their lament is heard by the Lord, who offers
compassion and grace to those deeply afflicted by such realities (Genesis
16;1-16, 25:21; Judges 13:2; 1 Samuel 1:11; Luke 1:5-13).
◦
All children are a gift from the Lord regardless
of the circumstances of their conception (Psalm 127:3)
◦
Though all children are to be fully respected
and protected, not all technological means of assisting human reproduction are
equally God-honoring or morally justified.
Why does IVF go against Creation Order?
- Biblical
creation order portrays the embodied union of husband and wife as the
singular normative expression for procreation (Genesis 1:27-28) - The
IVF process routinely generates more embryos than can be safely implanted,
thus resulting in the continued freezing, stockpiling, and ultimate
destruction of human embryos, some of whom may also be subjected to
medical experimentation. - IVF increasingly engages in dehumanizing methods for
determining suitability for life and genetic sorting, based on notions of
genetic fitness and parental preferences. - Estimates
suggest that between 1 million and 1.5 million human beings are currently
stored in cryogenic freezers in an embryonic state throughout the United
States, with most unquestionably destined for eventual destruction.
What are some of the “slippery slope” outcomes from IVF type
technology?
- Donating
(selling) of eggs and sperm (donor of eggs can be paid $7500, clinic can
get $130k for batch of 30 mature eggs) - Egg
freezing
◦
recently in the news when done by a well-known
politician
◦
what is missing in the above story is marriage
- Snow-flake
babies (unused frozen embryos)
◦
These are life, not just potential life
◦
it is unknown how many are stored
◦
They are the subjects of experiments up to 14
days
- Stem
cell research
◦
The desire of the research community to use stem
cells drawn from human embryos
◦
Results in the destruction of the embryo
- Gene
editing (eliminating defects)
◦
otherwise named genetic therapies
- Designer
babies
◦
Warned of by such varied figures as Aldous
Huxley and Francis Schaeffer
◦
Article
written by Albert Mohler and published Sept 26, 2026 at WORLD Opinions
speaks to a push in society to legitimize the selection of embryos based on
sex, IQ and intelligence aptitude
▪
Mohler references the August 15, 2026, article
in The Economist (one of the most establishment and influential periodicals in
elite culture) titled “In the Praise of Designer-ish Babies”
·
The Economist states: “Couples should be allowed
to select embryos on the basis of both disease resistance and IQ” and “Silicon
Valley wants to reshape the way humans are made.”
▪
This gives a human sovereign authority to
choose… (Gen. 3:5 - “...you shall be like God…”)
- Embryo
Screening
◦
another name for designer babies
◦
The ability to sort embryos for genetic traits
through polygenic screening (negative) subjecting to genetic analysis to
determine if it is acceptable.
◦
There is now ability to determine if your child
will have Down syndrome, and there currently is the pressure to abort
- Organ
harvesting
◦
This is probably a greater concern with the
prevalence of assisted suicide, but it is known to be happening with aborted
babies. Embryos are a fertile source.
- Embryo
mix-ups
◦
In Florida a caucasion couple were mistakenly
implanted with the wrong embryo, that which came from black parents
▪
Child was born just last December and are suing
the clinic for the mixup
- Surrogacy
(rent-a-womb)
◦
A woman is hired to carry the child of
biological cell parents
◦
Chinese billionaire father to over 100 babies
through IVF and surrogacy
◦
Used by same-sex couples
◦
Separates babies from marriage, hence Christians
cannot accept
- Is a
sperm donor a father? - Just a
few of the ethical and moral dilemmas when we step away from creation
order.
All of the above violate Creation Order by…
- Redefining
human relationships - Redefining
human reproduction - Redefining
human society - Redefining
adulthood - Note:
There is no marriage, or even a mother and a father necessary, just sign a
contract and get a baby.
Let’s go back the that Statement by the SBC – “Though all
children are to be fully respected and protected, not all technological means
of assisting human reproduction are equally God-honoring or morally justified.”
Sanctity and Dignity of Human Life
- Do we
as Christians truly believe that life begins at conception?
◦
If so, what does the use of IVF, which removes
the natural fertilization process from the union of a man and woman, result in?
- Should
a Christian couple pursue the use of IVF?
◦
There are many Christian couples who have used
IVF and are very thankful for their children.
▪
Those children are a greater good.
▪
However, are they now struggling with their
decision?
·
We need to be there for them and show them love
and compassion.
·
But we are also called to speak God’s Truth.
·
We as a church are late to this debate that is
nearing 50 years!
- Christians
have to look at a deeper level
◦
We are given in creation an order and a context
▪
The context for having children is the same
context for having sexual relations, and that is within the covenant of
marriage between a man and a woman. In that context, having children is
absolutely right and absolutely good. Be fruitful and multiply and fill the
earth. It’s not only a good thing, it is a divine command. That is God’s
purpose. That is the design of creation order for our good and God’s glory
◦
If you begin to take apart the context, you take
away the good of what God gave us in creation order.
▪
If you change the context, you are changing the
thing itself.
▪
That means rejecting, remodeling, redefining the
goods that God gave us in creation…
·
We want them on our terms
◦
Look to the temptation of Adam and Eve in the
garden: “you will be like God”
·
We want them shaped like we want them shaped
·
We want them to be what we want them to be.
- Truth:
Children are a greater good, no matter the circumstance.
◦
If you are a couple looking at IVF, or know one
that is, it is important as Christians to look at God’s design and seeking to
be in His will.
In closing, I as a follower of Christ, do not believe that
the use of IVF can be justified. But I am not going to condemn others that have
chosen this route. God forgives and only He can bring healing. We are called to
be a part of that healing process and to speak the truth of God’s Word.
Biblical Truth and Authority
(Oct 4)
- 2 Timothy 3:16 – “All Scripture is given by inspiration of
God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for
instruction in righteousness.” - Week after week, year after year, we study God’s Word. Verse by
verse, chapter by chapter, book by book. How much do we take the truths
that we learn with us as we go about our daily tasks? - It is easy for us to focus on the inspiration portion of the
above passage from 2 Timothy, but we should not overlook the words
speaking of all Scripture being… profitable. - We are told today that there is science, and there is religion,
and that they should be held apart. That is false, as we commanded by God
to look at Scripture as the foundation for ALL truth.
----------------------------------------------
One item of note is that I find
the resources put out by the EFCA to be a valuable tool in preparation for a
Sunday School class like this. There are many books out there on a variety of
theological and doctrinal topics. It is easy to get swept away by arguments
presented by charismatic authors. Referring back to the foundational statements
of belief that the EFCA holds to keeps me grounded and helps me avoid what Paul
warns Timothy of in his first letter, chapter 1, verses 3 through 5.
- “For the time will come when men will not put up with sound
doctrine. Instead, to suit their own desires, they will gather around them
a great number of teachers to say what their itching ears want to hear.
They will turn their ears away from the truth and turn aside to myths. But
you, keep your head in all situations, endure hardship, do the work of an
evangelist, discharge all the duties of your ministry.”
Step through how to access EFCA
resources from the Brooklyn website.
- Events – Resources
◦
EFCA Go
▪
Statement of Faith
▪
Explore Resources –
Resource Bundles
Where We Stand in the EFCA:
Denials and Affirmations
- On June 21, 2023, this document was published to address
current social and cultural trends that can create division among us. I
may touch on some of these trends and topics in coming weeks. - If you are interested, this is a good document that addresses
questions asked, concerns raised, and criticisms made about or against the
EFCA. It clarifies where we in the EFCA stand as we seek to make the
gospel of the Bible central.
EFCA Doctrinal Surveys
·
Every 5 years the
EFCA conducts a doctrinal survey of all its pastoral leaders. If you want to
know where our pastors stand on a variety of doctrinal issues this is a
fascinating view into the spiritual foundation of our churches.
·
The latest survey
was held in late 2023, and was compiled and released in October of 2024. It was
sent to just over 3,100 senior pastors and everyone credentialed by the EFCA.
46% completed the 50 question survey.
·
This survey discerns
a doctrinal pulse from those most often responsible for biblical and doctrinal
matter in the local church.
·
Opportunity to look
at trends
EFCA statement concerning the
Bible
·
We believe that God
has spoken in the Scriptures, both Old and New Testaments, through the words of
human authors. As the verbally inspired Word of God, the Bible is without error
in the original writings, the complete revelation of His will for salvation,
and the ultimate authority by which every realm of human knowledge and endeavor
should be judged. Therefore, it is to be believed in all that it teaches,
obeyed in all that it requires, and trusted in all that it promises.
Biblical Clarity and Authority:
Central to the Christian Faith
I have drawn much of the
following from the writings of Randy J. Guliuzza, from the Institute for
Creation Research (ICR).
Q – When God reveals Himself through the Bible, are the
words we read clear enough so everyone has a fair opportunity to learn of Him?
Can the average person understand the Bible by reading it without a theology
degree? Are the Bible’s words in the original languages comprehensible in and
of themselves so that they can be accurately translated to different languages?
Does someone need a Ph.D. in science to clearly see His workmanship throughout
nature, or can it be plainly understood by anyone?
- Romans 1:18-20 – “The wrath of God is being revealed from
heaven against all the godlessness and wickedness of men who suppress the
truth by their wickedness, since what may be known about God is plain to
them, because God has made it plain to them. For since the creation of the
world God’s invisible qualities – His eternal power and divine nature –
have been clearly seen, being understood from what has bee made, so that
men are without excuse.”
What is Biblical clarity and why
is is fundamental?
- Foundational doctrine that God clearly communicates to us
through our own reading of the Bible. - Perspicuity: The Holy Spirit inspired biblical authors to
communicate with words that are transparent and understandable, not hidden
or confusing. - God intends to communicate a lucid message through the normal
meaning of the Bible’s words in their normal context. Therefore, we reject…
◦
That words don’t
really mean what they say
◦
We need to extract
additional verbiage from the text
◦
Multiple messages
are embedded in the text
◦
There are multiple
degrees of complexity
- Note: Pastor has shared 10 principles for understanding the
Bible that I keep in my Bible. It is a reminder and it keeps me grounded
in Scripture and the text of Scripture alone.
The Biblical basis for Biblical
clarity
- Moses taught in Deut. 30:11-14 that Scripture does not require
interpreters: “Now what I am commanding you today is not too difficult
for you or beyond your reach. It is not up in heaven, so that you have to
ask, ‘Who will ascend into heaven to get it and proclaim it to us so we
may obey it?’ Nor is it beyond the sea, so that you have to ask, ‘Who will
cross the sea to get it and proclaim it to us so we may obey it?’ No, the
Word is very near you; it is in your mouth and in your heart so you may
obey it.” - Jesus said in John 16:13 that the Holy Spirit would personally
lead believers in understanding truth: “But when he, the Spirit of
truth comes, he will guide you into all truth…” - The Berean Christians in Acts 17:11 were not dependent on a
scholar to tell them biblical truth: “These were more fair-minded than
those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word word with all
readiness, and searched the Scriptures daily to find out whether these
things were so.”
◦
Today we have
multiple translations of the Bible, along with concordances and commentaries to
provide us assistance.
◦
Q - In Paul’s time the Bible was not compiled in a book
such as we have today. Think about what searching was like for these Berean
Christians at that time. What was their access to scrolls of the prophets like?
We do not know the exact nature of resources available to them, but we do know
that they diligently “searched the Scriptures daily”.
Biblical authority and
sufficiency stand on the clarity of scripture
- Biblical clarity is integral to the doctrine of biblical
authority and sufficiency. - Biblical authority means the Bible’s teaching are the standard
for measuring the truthfulness of ALL other claims.
◦
We are to believe
and obey the Bible
◦
The Bible is final
(no further revelation necessary)
◦
The Bible is to be
our informative guide
◦
This was clear at
the time of the Reformation – clerics had set themselves up to control laity by
telling Christians they could not understand the Bible for themselves.
- The content of the Bible is sufficient, information from
sources outside the Bible are not necessary for God to communicate to us.
It is through the Holy Spirit using Scripture the we “may be complete,
thoroughly equipped for every good work” – 2 Timothy 3:17
How Biblical clarity applies to
creation, the very beginning of the Bible
- Spoiler alert: I am going to step into an area that is a
passion of mine and that I hold to with confidence. I believe with 100%
confidence that we live and breath on a young earth, a planet that was
created and formed by God (Jesus) as revealed in the holy book of Genesis. - If we apply the consistent practice of giving the Bible’s words
their normal and literal meaning, then we must believe in the creation
account as revealed in the Bible. - A scientist is not needed to direct our understanding of the
Bible.
◦
However, when we
look at evidence available in the world today, scientists that view the
evidence through a biblical lens can affirm the words a written in the Bible
- If we question the Biblical text of the following events do we
risk bringing into doubt other teachings in the Bible…? (note: ask
for class to look at each verse and share the event that Scripture
relates)
◦
“the evening and
the morning were the first day” –
Genesis 1:5
◦
“according to its
kind” – Genesis 1:11
◦
“the LORD God
formed man of the dust of the ground” –
Genesis 2:7
◦
“the rib which
the LORD God had taken from man He made into a woman” – Genesis 2:22
◦
“the waters
prevailed exceedingly on the earth, and all the high hills under the whole
heaven were covered” – Genesis 7:19
◦
“in six days the
LORD made the heavens and the earth” –
Exodus 20:11; 31:17
◦
“as through one
man sin entered the world, and death through sin” – Romans 5:12
◦
“the world that
then existed perished, being flooded with water” – 2 Peter 3:6
Christians should never question
the clarity or authority of the Bible by allowing modern scientific philosophy
to trump God’s Word.
Q – Why has evolution become the standard, the accepted
theory of how we came into existence?
They are plainly seeking to
explain everything through a desire to deny the existence of a God that they
would then have to answer to.
- 1 Timothy 6:20-21 - “...guard what has been entrusted to
your care. Turn away from godless chatter and the opposing ideas of what
is falsely called knowledge, which some have professed and in so doing
have wandered from the faith.”
Confrontation between “Salvation
Issues” vs. Biblical Truth and Authority
How then do we approach issues
when professing Christians question the words that are found in the Bible or
elevate specific personal beliefs above all others?
- Don’t be argumentative – focus on the truths God is bringing
and context. All the Holy Spirit to convict through His Word.
Q – What other events and stories in the Bible do we hear
others doubt, whether it be non-believers or those who profess to be Christian?
- Creation of the world in 7 days, meaning we live on a young
earth - The flood was regional, not world-wide
- Jonah couldn’t possibly have been swallowed by a whale
- Hell is just a metaphor
- The virgin birth was really just an adaptation of how gods at
that time came into being
How about the truths that we
read of in the Bible that are difficult for the nonbeliever (and often the
believer) to reconcile with the world that we live in. (note: read what
Bible says, then ask for what the world says)
- The practice of homosexuality is a sin (the world celebrates
pride month)
◦
1 Cor. 6:9 - “Do
you not know that the wicked with not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be
deceived: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolaters nor adulterers nor male
prostitutes nor homosexual offenders...”
- The sanctity of life from the fertilization of the egg
(abortion is legal up until birth)
◦
Psalm 139:13-16 – “For
you created my inmost being; you knit me together in my monther’s womb. I
praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made; your works are
wonderful, I know that full well. My frame was not hidden from you when I was
made in the secret place. When I was woven together in the depths of the earth,
your eyes saw my unformed body. All the days ordained for me were written in
your bood before one of the came to be.”
- We are to respect and care for the elderly (assisted suicide is
encouraged)
◦
Lev. 19:32 – “Rise
in the presence of the aged, show respect for the elderly and revere your God.
I am the LORD.”
- Sex outside of marriage is a sin (living together before
marriage is expected)
◦
Matt. 5:27-28 – “You
have heard that it was said, ‘Do not commit adultery.’ But I tell you that
anyone who looks at a woman lustfully has already committed adultery with her
in his heart.”
- Jesus is the only way of salvation (there are many paths to
God)
◦
John 14:6 – “Jesus
answered, ‘I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father
except through me.’”
Conclusion
So lets circle back to where we
started when we were looking at how we should view the Bible as God’s Words
spoken with clarity that we should clearly understand if we are commited. How
should we who hold to Biblical Authority confront the non-believers (and the
nominal Christians)?
- We must recognize that the Bible is the total source of truth
and is the standard to determine truthfulness of all other sources of
information and correctness of behaviors.
◦
The teaching of the
Bible can be clearly understood
◦
The Bible’s original
words are verbally inspired by God
◦
All of the Bible’s
words are true
◦
The Bible has been
supernaturally preserved
- Therefore, biblical authority carries the imperative that all
of its teachings are to be believed, obeyed, and – most importantly – used
as the ultimate source of truth for a believer.
Setting the stage as we have is
necessary for discussions we will have in the coming weeks. If we express
little regard for the authority of the Bible, then we cannot confront the sin
that permeates us and our society. We, as Christians, define sin based on
Scripture, the world has to come up with laws and rules that define wrongs.
Therefore, those that hold power can enact whatever the experts or the majority
want.
Extra Notes:
Recently there have been
sensational headlines and reports that the ark has possibly been discovered.
The location in Turkey is one that has been believed to be the resting place of
the ark on and off again for decades. Here is the thing... Do we have the find
the actual remains of the ark in order for us to believe in the truth of the
Bible? (NO) Will such a find convince all nonbelievers?
- I highly doubt it will make any difference at all. Read Luke 16
about the rich man and Lazurus. - Belief is much more than physical evidence, it is a spiritual
matter. - We do not use evidence to judge God’s Word. We use God’s Word
as the foundation from which we correctly understand the evidence. – Ken
Ham
◦
Our ultimate
authority isn’t a radar scan or a drill core. It isn’t a piece of supposed
petrified wood. And it certainly isn’t the latest sensational headline. Our
ultimate authority is the infallible Word of God. God who was there and knows
everything. And ultimately what’s the most important message of Noah and the
flood?
▪
Judgment came
because of man’s wickedness, but God provided an ark of salvation. There was
only one door into the ark, and today there is only one door to salvation.
Jesus said in John 10:9 “I am the door; if anyone enters through Me, He will be
saved.”
- But here is the really good news about scientific findings
today...if we look at evidence that has been found through the lens of the
Bible, we will find that it actually confirms what the Bible says.
Everything.
◦
Tim Clarey, a
scientist with ICR has traveled around the world and found sediment layering
consistent with the Bible’s relating of the global flood. That is truly
amazing, yet my faith or your faith is not based on that.
Extra notes on Design vs
Selection
https://www.icr.org/article/why-biology-needs-theory-biological/
https://www.icr.org/article/14637
https://www.icr.org/article/14753
https://www.icr.org/article/14825
Notes on Dinosaurs and Fossils
https://www.icr.org/creation-foundations/dinosaurs-fossils/
Global Flood
The Devaluation of Life (Oct 18)
Recap of past two weeks
1) Biblical Clarity and Authority
Foundational doctrine that God clearly communicates to us through our own reading of the Bible.
The Holy Spirit inspired biblical authors to communicate with words that are transparent and understandable, not hidden or confusing.
God intends to communicate a lucid message through the normal meaning of the Bible’s words in their normal context. Therefore…
The words mean what they say
Do not extract additional verbiage from the text
Do not seek out multiple messages in the text (reading between the lines)
Do not create multiple degrees of complexity
2) The subversion of Creation Order
This is the order that God established in His work of creation.
After the fall, God reasserted it for our protection
We were created male and female
Marriage between a man and a woman
Children born within a marriage union is good
The sanctity of life
When we subvert creation order, then we devalue life. And that begins with life before birth. And that then can only lead to abortion.
Psalm 139:13-16
“For you created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made; your works are wonderful, I know that full well. My frame was not hidden from you when I was made in the secret place. When I was woven together in the depths of the earth, you eyes saw my unformed body. All the days ordained for me were written in your book before one of them came to be.”
On June 24, 2022, the Supreme Court overturned the ruling on Roe V. Wade. That was good. We believe in the sanctity of life. As God’s Word reveals in Psalms:
The EFCA has published the book Evangelical Conviction which says the following on page 75
“All human life—at whatever stage of development, from conception to death; at whatever socio-economic status; and at whatever level of physical or intellectual capability—is sacred, because all human beings are created in God’s image. Even when this image has been corrupted by our sin, every human being is still worthy of honor and respect. There is nothing more valuable in all of creation than a human life.” —Evangelical Convictions p. 75
Unfortunately the ruling that was fought for has brought about a renewed effort by many states to create and pass legislation that in some cases allow abortion right up to the moment of birth. We must recommit to our convictions and reflect on the truths found in Scripture. Just like in 1973, we are amazed at the desire of so many to enable the taking of an innocent life.
We have a firm footing in the statements that our church has put out that are firmly rooted in Scripture. Article 3 of the EFCA Statement of Faith on the Human Condition should ground us in the grace of God as we respond to the issue of abortion:
"We believe that God created Adam and Eve in His image, but they sinned when tempted by Satan. In union with Adam, human beings are sinners by nature and by choice, alienated from God, and under His wrath. Only through God’s saving work in Jesus Christ can we be rescued, reconciled and renewed."
Sin affects all of us as Paul shares in his letter to Rome
Romans 3:23 – “for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God”
All humanity is dead in sin. We are sinners by nature and by choice.
But Paul then shares wonderful news
Romans 5:8 – “But God demonstrates His own love toward us, in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us,”
Romans10:9 – “if you confess with your mouth Jesus as Lord and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, you will be saved.”
Romans 8:1 – “Therefore, there is now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus.”
This same hope is available to those who have experienced the brokenness of abortion. While sin separates us from God, we must remember that we all, including those who decide to terminate a pregnancy or participate by some other means can experience freedom from condemnation and receive God’s unmerited favor.
Article 8 of the EFCA Statement of Faith is titled Christian Living and provides us guidance:
"We believe that God's justifying grace must not be separated from His sanctifying power and purpose. God commands us to love Him supremely and others sacrificially, and to live out our faith with care for one another, compassion toward the poor and justice for the oppressed. With God’s Word, the Spirit’s power, and fervent prayer in Christ’s name, we are to combat the spiritual forces of evil. In obedience to Christ’s commission, we are to make disciples among all people, always bearing witness to the gospel in word and deed."
In the leadup to the reversal of Roe v. Wade, Greg Strand shared the following concerning the Scriptures and the sanctity of Life. (EFCA executive director of theology and credentialing)
All human beings are created in the image of God, the imago Dei, and thus have dignity and worth (Gen 1:26-27; 5:1, 3; 9:6; 1 Cor 11:7; Jas 3:9).
All of life is a gift from God (Acts 17:25) and therefore sacred, from conception to death, and beyond, and those who serve the “God of the living” (Matt 22:32; Mark 12:27; Luke 20:38) affirm the sanctity of life and care for all (Ps 139:13-18; Rom 13:8-10). Life is a gift from God, the Author and Giver of life, and is to be treated as such. Life is never ours to take (Gen 9:6; Ex 21:12; Lev 24:17; Num 35:31).
Since life is a gift from God, from conception to death, and beyond, we acknowledge it as such and give him thanks and praise for it. Life and breath are in God’s hand (Job 12:10), the Spirit made us and God Almighty gives us life (Job 33:4; cf. Ps 100:3).
God has compassion for those image-bearers who are most vulnerable (Deut. 10:18; Isa 1:17; Ps 68:5; Gal 2:10; Jas 2:14-17), and as his children we are to “be imitators of God” (Eph 5:1).
At the end of the day, as noted above, the essence of this moral matter rests in one absolute and ultimate truth: the personhood of the infant in utero. From conception an unborn baby is a human being created in the image of God (Gen. 1:26-28), fearfully and wonderfully made (Ps. 139:13-17), with dignity and worth (Gen 1:26-27; 5:1, 3; 9:6; 1 Cor 11:7; Jas 3:9). Therefore, it is always, everywhere, morally wrong intentionally to kill an innocent human person.
Where we now stand following the reversal of that 1973 ruling
13 states ban abortion at fertilization
8 states place no gestational limit on abortion
15 states allow abortion up to viability
The redefining of abortion as women’s healthcare
From Abortion to the Abortion Pill
Two pills have changed everything. Well over 60 years ago the contraceptive pill, or birth control pill changed the moral landscape. The sexual revolution as we know it would not have been possible without it. Let’s be clear, this separated sex and reproduction and eventually sex from marriage. And now we have another pill that truly takes us into the pit of moral obtuseness.
Here is the description from Wikipedia:
“Mifepristone, also known by its developmental code name RU-486, is a drug typically used in combination with misoprostol to bring about a medical abortion during pregnancy. This combination is 97% effective during the first 63 days (9 weeks) of pregnancy, and is effective in the second trimester as well.”
Note: This is available in many parts of our country through the mail!
In April of 2025, the Ethics and Public Policy Center came out with a report that says in essence that this pill harms women. Over 10% of all women who have used it have experienced serious complications.
That was the safety side of this medication, but what about the efficacy? The efficacy has to do with how efficient the drug is in killing an unborn human being. It is indeed a very effective early term abortifacient. And just how long into the term of the pregancy? If you recall back to that Wikipedia statement it said 9 weeks, and that it was effective in the second trimester! That is over 13 weeks!
That report I referenced from the EPPC also cites that about two-thirds of all abortions in the United States were by means of this drug. The landscape has shifted from abortion clinics (which would entail a certain stigma since you physically had to go there) to an easy mail-order process.
What then is to be our response as the Body of Christ?
Women who have pursued the end of a pregnancy using any method will suffer!
Pray and be ready to support the women that have gone through such a procedure.
Pray for the women in this Body of Christ that God has granted a heart of compassion as they provide godly love and counsel to these women
Remember Romans 5:8 where it says that we are all sinners.
Pray specifically for wisdom for the pro-life movement
Pray for families with young children, the Moms and Dads who may be struggling. The recent trial for Lindsay Clancy and the ghastly support shown for a woman who murdered her children, followed by a number of other women who took the same murduous actions. Pray that God gives us the ability to see when Moms are struggling and to come alongside them.
What we are truly facing is a culture of death. This culture is wholly opposed to the gospel of life. As we have seen in the shift to an abortion pill is that the culture of death will do anything it can to advance its purposes, at the expense of women’s physical and spiritual health and at the extreme cost of unborn human life.
And that culture of death brings us to the other end of life and the push for assisted suicide.
If you do any browsing, you will immediately find that there is a push to use more “friendly” terms
“Death with Dignity”
Personal Autonomy
On June 6, 2019, Albert Mohler (president of Southern Baptist Theological Seminary) made the following observation in his The Briefing daily analysis:
“One of the sad lessons of history is that you can’t have the denial and subversion of human dignity and the sanctity of human life at one end of the human life span without inevitably seeing the same denial at the other end of the human life span.”
“So, even as at the beginning of the human life span we have seen abortion indicate, horrifyingly so, the denial of human dignity and the sanctity of human life, we also see the very same erosion of human dignity when it comes to euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. A society that will kill in the womb will eventually kill in the nursing home bed. That is simply a unified logic. If that doesn’t take place, it’s only for a matter of time until the society works out that logic and the culture of death wins at both the beginning and the end of the life span.”
This started in the countries of The Netherlands, Belgium and Luxembourg.
Began as legislation that allowed physician assisted suicide only in the case of someone who was relatively aged and facing intractable suffering from a terminal disease.
But soon the grounds became broader
Not only terminal disease, but just suffering
Then from physical pain to psychological or emotional pain.
Then from adults only to children
In the Netherlands a 16 year-old can request euthanasia on their own. A 12 to 15 year-old may seek it with their parents consent!
Recently a baby was euthenized
The slide of the euthanasia culture we are seeing in Canada
MAID
Barriers that are initially put up are gradually eroded and worn down. The speed bumps have basically been entirely removed.
A terminal illness with a likely death within 3 to 6 months – gone.
Assessment outside a Tim Hortons
The National Post headline reads...”Ontario man dies of MAID [that’s medical assistance in dying] after being assessed outside Tim Horton’s.”
The physician conducted his evaluation outside a coffee shop, then drove the individual to the place where the death was brought about.
This is a redefinition of medicine
Our society is buying into an absolutely idolatrous understanding of personal autonomy such that anyone evidently can demand on the basis of personal autonomy that medical personnel facilitate them by bringing about their own death.
1 in 20 deaths come about by some form of euthanasia.
In April Canada reached 100,000 people euthanized
Just 2 months ago the Quebec College of Physicians confirmed its support of expanding Canada’s euthanasia regime to include babies with severe deformities or syndromes
In a few minutes I’ll be sharing the stories of two women who would have fallen under this murderous umbrella.
Look at Genesis 3:4-5 where the serpant says:
“You will not die,...For God knows that when you eat from it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God, knowing good and evil.”
There in the garden of Eden the lie of self came to be, and we see it all around us today in the idolotry of personal autonomy...
self-love
self-esteem
self-confidence
self-care
self-realization
self-determination
being my best self
Where do we now stand here in the U.S.?
14 states allow “medical aid in dying”
These states affect one third of the American population
16 states are considering
In CA and NM, the waiting period is just 48 hours
Two states have removed residency requirements.
Minimum age?
Calling it “Dignity in dying”
The selling of death as compassion
In New York an advocacy organization is named Compassion and Choices
As Christians, it is never compassionate to kill
It is, however, compassionate to alleviate pain
There is also the need to recognize that there is a distinction between those who are alive and those who in the active dying process
Christians cannot accelerate that dying process, but we can respond with appropriate medical treatments to try to alleviate anything from pain to confusion.
This is not an easy subject to address, Rhonda and I have both seen parents and grandparents go through painful years struggling with cancer, strokes, broken bones, dementia and other reminders of the effects of sin. But out of them have come moments that demonstrate God’s grace, such as when my Dad held our youngest son Matthew when he was just 3 days old, and God took him home just hours later.
Dignity in living – the Christian approach
share about lives of Crista and Carma Smidt
My experience at church and Sibley Christian
Rhonda’s friendship in college
Nephew William took her to prom
Normalizing Sinful Relationships and Sexual Behaviors - Part 1 (Oct 25)
Recap of past two weeks
1) Biblical Clarity and Authority
Foundational doctrine that God clearly communicates to us through our own reading of the Bible.
The Holy Spirit inspired biblical authors to communicate with words that are transparent and understandable, not hidden or confusing.
God intends to communicate a lucid message through the normal meaning of the Bible’s words in their normal context. Therefore…
The words mean what they say
Do not extract additional verbiage from the text
Do not seek out multiple messages in the text (reading between the lines)
Do not create multiple degrees of complexity
2) The subversion of Creation Order
This is the order that God established in His work of creation.
After the fall, God reasserted it for our protection
We were created male and female
Marriage between a man and a woman
Children born within a marriage union is good
The sanctity of life
3) The devaluation of life
Abortion
The Abortion Pill
Euthanasia
Living with Dignity as God designed
Normalizing Sinful Relationships and Sexual Behaviors
1 Corinthians 6:18-20 – “Flee from sexual immorality. All other sins a man commits are outside his body, but he who sins sexually sins against his own body. Do you not know that your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit, who is in you, whom you have received from God? You are not your own; you were bought at a price. Therefore honor God with your body.”
Available Resources
FAQ1 - How should local churches respond Supreme Court decisions regarding same-sex marriage?
Writing on behalf of the majority, Justice Anthony Kennedy sought to respond to some of the concerns raised by religions and those with religious convictions. Those who do not agree with the new law that legalized same-sex marriage will be protected under the First Amendment (“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”).
Finally, it must be emphasized that religions, and those who adhere to religious doctrines, may continue to advocate with utmost, sincere conviction that, by divine precepts, same-sex marriage should not be condoned. The First Amendment ensures that religious organizations and persons are given proper protection as they seek to teach the principles that are so fulfilling and so central to their lives and faiths, and to their own deep aspirations to continue the family structure they have long revered.
Knowing religious liberty has been narrowed over the years, and with concern regarding possible implications of this new law on religious liberty, and to ensure Kennedy’s words are not just rhetoric, The First Amendment Defense Act was introduced to clarify, strengthen and defend religious liberty. As part of this defense this bill prevents federal intrusion and government retaliation, specifically against those individuals and institutions who support traditional marriage.
The First Amendment Defense Act (S. 1598, H.R. 2802) would prevent any federal agency from denying a tax exemption, grant, contract, license, or certification to an individual, association, or business based on their belief that marriage is a union between a man and a woman. For example, the bill would prohibit the IRS from stripping a church of its tax exemption for refusing to officiate same-sex weddings.
It is interesting to note, that two legal issues that strike at the heart of key biblical truths and central issues of living out our Christian faith – abortion and same-sex marriage – are both rooted in the 14th Amendment: In 1973, Roe v. Wade, it was made law that the “right” to privacy extended to a woman's decision to have an abortion; in 2015, Obergefell v. Hodges, it was made law that the “‘right’ to marry is a fundamental ‘right’ inherent in the liberty of the person.”
There are things we can learn from these two laws that we believe compromise biblical truth and convictions, how we have responded in the past, and how we ought to respond in the future. In the first few days after the decision a number of Christians have begun to think along these lines as they ponder further how we ought to process this and how we ought to respond. Theologically and pastorally, we affirm God is the sovereign one who remains sovereign as he unfolds his providential plan in this fallen-redeemed-not-yet-glorified world. We also affirm that we do not have a definitive answer to the practical questions of “what do we now do?” It is not that there are no answers or responses, but wise, and discerning responses that will be faithful and fruitful take some time to think through, ponder and pray over.
This will impact believers, churches and church-related institutions, but we do not know in what way. It is most likely that church-related institutions rather than churches themselves will be most affected by this new law. Many individuals and organizations are researching, consulting, pondering and praying about next steps and how to help God’s people to know how to navigate through them. One of those organizations is the National Association of Evangelicals, of which the EFCA is a member.
You can be assured the EFCA will work prayerfully and diligently to provide instruction, guidance and resources for pastors and churches. It is not as if this is catching us completely unaware, but it is a new day that will require a new way of thinking about and responding to this. Our biblical and theological commitment remains the same.
It is likely that the Spiritual Heritage Committee will be enlisted to work on how best to guide our thinking and responding, biblically, theologically and pastorally. We have also provided resources and policies.
FAQ2: What is the EFCA position on homosexuality and same-sex marriage?
The EFCA affirms the inerrancy and authority of the Bible (cf. Article 2) which grounds and guides our understanding of and response to homosexuality and same-sex marriage.
We have a policy for those pursuing credentialing in the EFCA regarding “Homosexual Belief and Conduct” that states the EFCA will not credential one who engages in homosexual conduct or one who does not believe that homosexual behavior is sinful, even though remaining celibate.
We also have a statement on same-sex marriage that provides guidance to local churches who are writing a policy on this issue: “A Church Statement on Human Sexuality: Homosexuality and Same-Sex Marriage – A Resource for EFCA Churches.”
Credentialing: Homosexual Belief and Conduct
The EFCA will not credential one who engages in homosexual conduct or one who does not believe that homosexual behavior is sinful, even though remaining celibate.
Clarification statement:
While tragically, as a result of the fall, believers might experience sexual attraction to those of the same sex, Christ’s followers will not affirm this as part of God’s plan for their lives nor build their identities around such attractions. Therefore, persons will not view themselves, or refer to themselves as homosexuals, but rather define their identity as new creatures in Christ. One may (and indeed, honesty may demand that they must) acknowledge the reality of same-sex attraction, but must ground their identity in Christ, not in their sexual attractions. Thus, any person who embraces a homosexual identity, even if celibate, acts in rebellion against God’s created order of male and female, demonstrating that they have not fully repented from homosexual lust and behavior.
Resource on Homosexuality and Same-Sex "Marriage"
Never have the sexual ethics of our culture been more confused and contorted. The need for a clear voice from the church on these matters is critical, both for the health of our own community and for our faithful witness to the world.
This Statement, drawn from Scripture as our ultimate authority, sets forth a Christian vision of human sexuality as a good gift of God. The divine design for sexual expression within the commitment of marriage between a man and a woman is fundamental to the well-ordering of human society and is integral to human flourishing. We desire to articulate this ethic as moral truth binding on us all while recognizing our need of God's grace and forgiveness in the ways that we all fall short of this divine ideal, specifically as it relates to homosexuality and same-sex "marriage".
This Statement is not an official policy and therefore has no formal authority in the EFCA. It is written by the Spiritual Heritage Committee, with input from others, as a Resource for local EFC churches. Any authority this Statement would have, in whole or in part, would be determined by the local EFC church.
Biblical Sexuality and the Covenant of Marriage: Resolution (2017)
What Pastoral Counsel Do You Have for Christian Parents Who Have Children Who Come Out as Homosexual? (Albert Mohler Feb 28 The Briefing, Part IV)
How do the Christian parents hold onto their faith in the inerrancy of God’s word and respond to their child in a way that is godly-wise and helpful? One of the things I know in so many years of doing this is that so many faithful Christians answer their own question in their own way, whether they recognize it or not. These parents clearly affirm the gospel. They are Christian parents who affirm the inerrancy of the Word of God, and that means that all of God’s promises are true. But we are not promised unconditionally that our children will walk with the Lord. That’s a very hard thing, but it’s true even in the Scriptures.
We are certainly told to raise our children in the nurture and admonition of the Lord, but we are not able to keep them from going into sin, even into identifying with disbelief, or even into, say, an LGBTQ identity. And in this case, the parents have responded rightly. They pray for their child, they bear witness to the truth to their child, but they also ask the question, “How do we support other parents in a similar situation?” And they go on to say, “Sometimes these things are not discussed at church out of a sense of shame.” That’s where I just want emphatically to speak to Christian parents. You bear no shame in this. This is something that should be a pain, a struggle, a prayer concern that is shared by members of the family of faith who love you and know you. We’re not able, in our own wisdom to know how to negotiate all of these things. We need the local body of Christ in faithfulness under the authority of Scripture by the power of the gospel to help us to think through many of these things.
A Classic Case of Theological Collapse: How A Pastor-Father’s Acceptance of His Son’s Homosexual Lifestyle Led to the Eventual Abandonment of Biblical Christianity (Albert Mohler Feb 24 The Briefing)
A pastor in California named Bill White. When his son came out as gay he transformed his beliefs so that now he is an advocate for LGBTQ inclusion in the church.
Bill White has a diary of his prayers that is shared
“My theology is changing, Father. It’s been a deep undercurrent for a couple of years now, but it’s surfacing in new ways and with real potency these days. I think there are two main things that are unnerving for me.” This is the father, the pastor writing. “The first is that I no longer know how to read the Scriptures. There’s a tinge of doubt, of wariness, of skepticism when I read. How do I know what’s there is from you? How do I sift out the human contribution? I’m reading Scripture differently with an edge.”
“The second area that’s unnerving for me is in regard to morality. If I can get to the point where homosexuality is moral, how much does that change the rest of my morality? Sure, I had the conversation with Timothy that I value purity and that I’d like to see him save sex for marriage. It was a bit of an odd conversation because how do I get to land at the point of no sexual intercourse before marriage but then redefine marriage? At what point do my sexual mores change? How about the morality of cussing, of generosity, of lying? How situational do things become? How open are the Scriptures to reinterpretation on these things and how about universalism, heaven and hell. Jesus, I want to do some real thinking about what it looks like for me to cling to you, to know you, to love you, and to build my theology on you and not on the Scriptures.”
“I want to build my theology on you,” speaking to Christ, “and not on the Scriptures.”
Here is what this pastor is basically saying:
“I’m going to have to choose between the scriptures and some other understanding and I’m going to go with the other understanding at the expense of the Scriptures.”
Albert Mohler statement:
“This is what it all comes down to. What access to Jesus do we have but by the Scriptures? This is an invented projected Jesus separated from the Scriptures. This is exactly what we are to avoid. This is a dangerous mysticism that falls over into theological liberalism.”
Faithful Christians can’t say that we have any access to Jesus apart from Scripture. What do we know about Scripture? Jesus is the one who pointed to the Scriptures and said, “These are they that testify of me.”
Authentic Christianity is biblical Christianity. And the Scripture’s authority is absolutely beyond negotiation.
Here’s a classic example of the fact that once you forfeit the high ground of that view of Scripture, then you can simply say, “I like that verse. I don’t like this verse. I find this to be revealing of Christ. Not that.” You can set Christ against Scripture, which is exactly what Christ did not allow to take place.
Biblically minded Christians have to be continually aware of the fact that we must order our loves in accordance with Scripture. We are commanded to love our children, but we are also commanded to hate sin. And if we truly love our children and understand the authority of Scripture pointing to the very character of God, then we cannot love them into sin. We must love them as we pray for them to come out of sin.
Gender and Sexuality in the Church
The TX/OK EFCA District
The following teachings were drawn from this excellent video series.
Session I: How did we get here? // Gender + Sexuality & The Church
Bruce Jenner sat down with Diane Sawyer in 2015
“When God was looking down and making little Bruce, he said, ‘Let’s give him all these wonderful qualities...But you know, everybody’s got to have something [to deal with]. What are we going to give him? I know, let’s give him the soul of a female.’ My brain is much more female than it is mail. It’s hard for people to understand that, but that’s what my soul is. For all intents and purposes, I am a woman...my heart and soul and everything I do in life [is this] female part of me. I was not genetically born that way…”
“What I’m doing is going to do some good and we’re going to change the world. I firmly believe that – that we’re going to make a difference in the world with what we’re doing.”
Reaction: What if the world had already changed? How did we get to a place where Bruce Jenner could say what he did and people can understand it?
Idea #1: The Bible teaches both how God created us and how sin distorted us.
The Biblical Sex Ethic
The Bible’s view of the body - Gen. 1:26-29
We are deeply integrated beings – we are embodied souls and ensouled bodies
The human body is part of God’s revelation in creation. It is not meant to be discarded or ignored when making moral decisions.
The body is affected by sin, but the original design of male and female remain intact.
The body is essential to understand human identity and morality – who we are and what we should do.
God’s design for sex is: One man, one woman, in marriage, for life.
God’s design for sex is rooted in God’s design for marriage (Gen. 2:24; Matt. 19:1-6)
God’s design for marriage reveals Jesus’ relationship to the church (Eph. 5:22-33)
The Problem
All of us are born with sexual sin and brokenness
Attraction and behaviors that are contrary to God’s original design for us. These attractions and behaviors manifest themselves with the opposite sex, the same sex, or a mixture of both.
Sex and Sin
We are all created in God’s image, but we are also all born with a sinful nature.
Jesus and the Biblical authors assume the presence of deeply felt attractions and desires that we must say “NO” to.
This means saying “NO” to sexual desires, attractions, and behaviors outside of God’s Design.
Idea #2: Our cultural moment is the result of a massive collision between the Biblical Sexual Ethic and the Modern Notions of Identity.
Modern Notions of Identity
Modern Cultural Developments
Prior to 1800s sexuality was understood in terms of behavior, not identity
Changed with Sigmund Freud
Human nature was deeply sexuality
He and contemporaries were first to use the terms heterosexual and homosexual to describe people’s sexual attractions.
Human sexuality was at the core of human identity.
Romanticism (18th-19th century)
Secular philosophy that elevated personal feelings over human reason
Rejected the Christian doctrine of original sin
Grounded morality in the natural dispositions of the human heart
Highest virtue: Self Expression
Existentialism
Elevated personal freedom over human reason
Rejected the Christian doctrine of original sin
Rejected any notion of a human nature
Grounded morality in the expressions of the human will.
Highest virtue: Authenticity
Expressive Individualism (20th -21st century)
Coined by sociologist Robert Bellah in 1996
Each person has a “true self” that needs to be expressed
This self-expression is essential to human happiness
Any social conformity (eg. to one’s family, community, religion, etc.) is seen as a threat.
Taken Together
Human Identity: Has become radically individualized, sexualized and emotionalized.
Human Identity: Not something we receive, it’s something we construct.
Human Sexuality: Is no longer what we have; it’s who we are.
Human Purpose: No longer to become virtuous by aligning with our nature; it’s to become authentic by aligning with our feelings.
How have these come into our culture?
Entertainment
Education
Idea #3: Our way forward is the way of basic Christian discipleship.
The Church’s Response
Part of the Answer: Our present moment is the result of the cultural collision between the Biblical Sexual Ethic and the Modern Notions of Identity.
Perception is that we hate them
They want to hear that we love them and care about them
Consider how we can communicate our love and compassion before we communicate the truth
Barna Study in 2017: What Millennials want when they visit church - complaints
Moral failures in leadership (35%)
Christians are judgmental (87%)
Christians are hypocritical (85%)
Christians are insensitive to others (70%)
Christians are anti-homosexual (91%)
The Anatomy of Deconversion – John Marriot
“A disproportionate number of deconversions have in common a similar type of Christian background. Repeatedly, deconversion stories exhibit aspects of fundamentalism...while some former Christians testify that their home and church experiences were gracious, loving, and life-giving, the vast majority do not. On the contrary, more often than not, they have little good to say about their time as Christians. Words such as strict, narrow-minded, legalistice, and fundamentalist were commonly ascribed to their Christian experience.”
What Should we do Now?
Can’t over-correct and jump to progressive Christianity
Some of this cannot be helped: the message of the cross will always be offensive to some people (John 15:18-25; 1 Cor. 1:18)
But while the gospel is offensive, we should strive not to be (Romans 12:18)
We must do everything we can to be like Jesus: full of grace and truth (John 1:14)
Reparative Therapy Movement
Today almost all leaders from this movement now support LGBT+ relationships and believe reparative therapy caused more harm than good.
The legacy of the movement hangs over the Christian witness today
Common phrase: “You can’t pray the gay away.”
Many LGBTQ people have this in the back of their minds when we talk to them about “change,” or “transformation.”
The big idea for them: “I didn’t choose this; I can’t change this – and I shouldn’t have to.”
But… Is this kind of change possible?
Yes – it is possible. God can heal anyone of any kind of brokenness – physical, sexual, emotional, etc.
there are some reported cases of this happening
Attractions remained, but they walked away from the lifestyle
But, while it is possible, it is not promised in Scripture.
We all have our crosses to bear and our thorns to endure (Luke 9; 2 Cor. 12)
Going Forward
We must remain committed to the Biblical Sex Ethic
We must be aware of how the Modern Notions of Identity form the default assumptions for most people.
We must be incredibly sensitive to the Perceptions and Experiences of People about the Church
This enables us to Interpret and Respond Biblically
Missionaries
We must understand the culture and context of the people we are ministering to.
This is truly a mission field.
Interpret Biblically (the doctrine of Imago Dei)
Reclaim the role of the human body in the formulation of human identity – “who we are” and “how God made us.”
Maintain the distinction between original design and inherited brokenness.
Emphasize the true identity God has given people as His image-bearers. E.g. People are not just their sexual desires.
Respond Biblically
We must include sexuality and gender within our discipleship efforts.
We must strive to create an atmosphere of grace and compassion.
We must engage the mess – be honest and be willing to help people surrender and submit – regardless of their struggle.
Focus on Basic Discipleship
Mark 8:34-35 - “If anyone wants to follow me, let him deny himself, take up his cross, and follow me. For whoever want to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life because of me and the gospell will save it.”
Sam Allberry (pastor and same-sex attracted man in the UK)
“The cost of discipleship looks high for those coming to faith from an LGBTQ+ background. But that must not disguise the fact that the cost of discipleship is high for everyone. Jesus said, “If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself, take up his cross, and follow me” (Mark 8:34) The key word is anyone. To follow Jesus, all of us will have to say a deep and profound “no” to some of our deepest intuitions and longings...there will be times when it feels like obedience to Him is taking life from us. And yet the glorious pradox is that by going through this loss, we are actually gaining life. By denying self and following Jesus we don’t become less who we are; we become most truly ourselves.”
For further reading: Carl R. Truman books
The Rise and the Triumph of the Modern Self
Strange New World
Resources
Love Thy Body – Nancy R. Pearcey
Gender Ideology-What do Christians Need to Know? – Sharon James
Idea #1: The Biblical Ethic is and Embodied Ethic
Theology of Gender
Genesis 1:26-28
Man created in the image of God
Male and female He created them, built in to the creation
The significance of the Body
God created us male and female, emphasis on the created part
Jesus viewed Genesis 1:27 as normative for understanding human identity and behavior (Matthew 19-God's design for marriage)
Jesus affirmed the goodness of the human body (the physical body)
Scripture says that for Christians, our bodies are temples of the Holy Spirit (1 Cor. 6:18-20)
We will have redeemed bodies in the new creation (Revelation 21)
Genesis to Revelation God affirms the goodness of the human body
In creation God affirms the goodness of the human body when He creates the human body as male and female
In the incarnation God affirms the goodness of the human body by His Son taking on human flesh, becoming a person
In His resurrection, Jesus in His human body was
In His ascension He is physically present with the Father
In the new creation God will make all things new
Gnosticism
Denied the inherent goodness of material creation
Believed that physical matter was evil
God and the Transgender Debate - Andrew T. Walker
"Gnosticism emphasizes that a person's self-awareness is different than and more important than their physical body. Gnosticism says that there is an inherent tension between our true selves and the bodies we inhabit. The idea that our true self is different than the body we live in communicates that our body is something less than us, and can be used, shaped, and changed to match how we feel. The concept that our gender [identity] can be different than our biological sex is a modern form of the old Gnostic idea/"
Science - (Resource: Why Gender Matters by Leonard Sax)
Basic Biology
Every cell in our body is either male or female
External differences in size
internal differences - women have bigger brains, develop faster
Strength
Women have a better sense of smell
Women have a better sense of sound
Developmental (true in most, not all)
Interests: When given paper and crayons, girls tend to draw flowers and trees while boys draw monsters, aliens, and action scenes (my grandsons draw monster trucks)
Relationships: Boys tend to make friends shoulder-to-shoulder; whereas girls tend to make friends face-to-face
After fighting, boys are more likely to become better friends, while girls are more likely to have longer-lasting hurt feelings.
Aggression: Boys are more likely to need something to harness their physical aggression.
Risk: Boys are much more likely to engage in physically risky behavior (climbing trees or buildings). Boys are much more likely to over-estimate their abilities and under-estimate the risks involved.
Idea #2: Transgender Ideology separates the human body from human identity.
Transgender Ideology
Judith Butler, Gender Theorist
"Gender is a 'fiction,' a 'fabrication,' and a 'fantasy' that can be made and remade at will...Gender is theorized as radically independent of sex, gender itself becomes a free-floating artifice, with the consequences that man and masculine might just as easily signify a female bode as a male one, and woman and feminine a male body as easily as a female one...The body is itself a [social] construction."
We no longer receive our identity (from God), but we construct our identity (self)
Affirms a distinction between biological sex (outward) and gender identity (inward)
Biological sex is what you are assigned at birth (what you have); gender identity is what you discover over time (who you are)
Makes an identity out of our internal feelings
In education
Disintegration of the person
Transgender Ideology (cont'd)
Gender-Non-Conforming: someone who doesn't identify with their biological sex because their gender-expressions don't fit traditional roles or stereotypes.
The girl who likes to get in the dirt and play with boys, so now she is trans
Agender, Non-Binary, & Gender-Queer: those who don't identify as a man or a woman or whose identity lies outside the traditional gender binary or male and female.
Transgender: someone who identifies with a gender other than their biological sex.
In all cases: the intrinsic significance of the body is denied.
Biology must conform to psychology; outward must conform to inward.
The Logic of Transgenderism (you are your feelings)
Premise 1: If I deeply feelI am X, then I am X
Premise 2: I deeply feel I am X
Therefore: I am X
Why is this limited to gender?
Headline: Dutch man, 69, starts legal fight to identify as 20 years younger
Race activist Rachel Dolezal: "I identify as black"
If we use that logic then any of these can work, and can lead to....
Some important questions for us as the church Body
Do we actively celebrate God's gift of gender?
intentional effort to affirm what it means to be a boy or a girl
Do we explain the purpose and blessing of gender?
Do we emphasize a persons gender when we teach about their identity?
We really and truly believe that who you are is connected to the fact that your are a boy (or a girl)
Some have been raised that they can be anything that they want to be.
Some truth, but there really are some not so true things (they can be a different gender)
Start with and affirm what God has made them to be: a boy or a girl.
Have we assumed too much?
Do we just assume that everyone attending Brooklyn know this, because of Genesis 1 and 2?
Have we just assumed that our kids know the blessedness of gender, not just the givenness of gender?
Normalizing Sinful Relationships and Sexual Behaviors Part 2 (Nov 1)
Idea #1: God's commands for sex are rooted in God's design for sex.
Josh Gatewood video series
Session III: Homosexuality in the Church
Truth: We are talking about people, we must approach them with humility and compassion!
Books
What Does the Bible Really Teach about Homosexuality? - Kevin Deyoung
Love Thy Body - Nancy R. Pearcey
Holy Sexuality and the Gospel - Christopher Yuan
Roadmap
The Biblical Sex Ethic
Biblical Challenges
Common Objections
The Biblical Sex Ethic
Rooted in the Bible
Genesis 1:26-28
People in the homosexual community are still image bearers of God
Genesis 2:24-25
Jesus quotes this verse in Matthew 19
God's design for sex is: One man, one woman, in marriage, for life.
God's Design for Sex is rooted in God's Design for Marriage
Starting in Genesis is important, not with Gen 19 Lev 18 Romans 1, at the beginning with God's perfect design
God's design for marriage reveals Jesus' relationship to the Church (Eph. 5 :22-33)
The picture of a human marriage between a man and a woman are to reflect the marriage of Jesus and the Church.
The gender of the people in the marriage is intentional.
Sam Allberry (Is God anti-gay?)
"A man and a man, or a woman and a woman, cannot reflect the union of Christ and the church...The teaching of Genesis, reinforced and expanded by Jesus...is that sex is a good gift that God has given exclusively for marriage, and that in order for marriage to fulfill the purposes for which God [created] it, marriage must be between one man and one woman."
"All of us have desires that are warped as a result of our fallen nature. Desires for things God has forbidden are a reflection of how sin has distorted me, not of how God has made me."
All of us are born with a sinful nature and have desires that are contrary to God's design
Important Distinctions
Same-Sex Attraction vs. Same-Sex Behavior.
The attractions may not be chosen, but the behavior is.
People may deeply feel homosexual attraction and that's all they've known.
Remember our sinful nature.
Feeling and Attractions
The question is not: what do I feel?
The question is: what do I do with these feelings?
Better question: What does God want me to do with these feelings?
Modern Biblical Challenges
Challenge #1: The Bible vs modern psychology
People in this community have been hurt by the church, grieve and grow from.
Yet we cannot reject the truth of Scripture
Grace and Truth
Learn from the modern sciences, but do not compromise the authority of the Bible.
The classic texts (clobber texts)
Old Testament
Genesis 19 (Sodom and Gomorrah)
Leviticus 18:22 & 20:13
New Testament
Romans 1:26-27
1 Cor. 6:9-11
1 Timothy 1:10
Some perspective
For almost 2,000 years, there has been almost universal agreement on what the Bible teaches about homosexuality
New interpretations didn't arise until the sexual revolution in the 1960s.
Today, scholars and thinkers who advocate these new interpretations are known as Revisionists.
There is a mountain of scholarship responding to these claims.
Challenge #2: Old Testament Objections
Genesis 19 (Sodom and Gomorrah)
Leviticus 18:22 & 20:13
Tough, pointed, sharp passages
Two basic concerns with revisionists:
Inconsistency: Christians don't obey the Mosaic law on things like animal sacrifice, clothing material, or diet. Why should we obey it when it comes to homosexuality?
Fulfillment: Since the Mosaic law was fulfilled in Christ (Matt. 5:17), it is no longer binding on believers today.
Response
If an OT law is repeated in the NT, then it is still morally binding on the believers today.
The NT continue the holiness laws, the ethics and behaviors
Romans 1, 1 Cor. 6, 1 Tim. 1
Very Important
The Leviticus passages do not say that people are an abomination.
The Leviticus passages say the acts are an abominations.
We must make it clear to people that God does not see them as an abomination, but as people worth loving and giving His life for.
Romans 5:8
Challenge #3: New Testament Objections
Romans 1:26-27
Claim: The authors of the Bible only condemned certain kinds of homosexuality - like pederasty, prostitution, and rape. They never condemned monogamous, mutually loving gay relationships.
If the authors of the Bible had known of the loving same-sex relationships of today they would not have condemned them (argument from silence)
Quotes are available explaining this in more depth that I will not share here.
Response
Not True: The Biblical authors were aware of the full spectrum of homosexual expression - including monogamous, committed relationships. (Paul spoke of behavior, identity was not invented until recently)
Speculation: This argument assumes that if Paul would have known about mutually -loving, committed same-sex relationships (like we see today), then he wouldn't have condemned them.
Important Principle: Always let Scripture interpret Scripture.
Extra-biblical text can mislead
Remember Jesus - "Have you not read..."
Paul is not just thinking about Greco-Roman practices; he's thinking about Genesis 1-2.
Key Phrase: Paul condemns homosexual behavior because it is "contrary to nature".
"Contrary to Nature" was consistently used in the ancient world to describe deviant sexual activity, which specifically included homosexual activity.
Paul's point is that people engage in sexual behavior that was contrary to "biological design."
1 Cor. 6 and 1 Timothy 1:10
Can be treated the same as Romans passage
Translation Claims
Because the term homosexual did not come into our vocabulary until 1800s, then our translations are not correct.
However, the phrase "arsenokoites" (sp?) which our translations interpret as "homosexual" actually means "a sodomite-abuser of self with mankind" or in more plain terms as the latest NIV and ESV use: "men who have sex with men".
Latest NIV and ESV does use the actual meaning.
Challenge #4: Jesus never said anything about homosexuality
Response
What follows? Does that mean we don't know what Jesus believed about homosexuality?
Are there other sexual practices Jesus never mentioned (eg. bestiality, internet pornography, etc.)?
Matthew 19 makes it clear: Jesus affirmed Genesis 1-2 as God's sexual ethos for all mankind.
Jesus condemned sexual immorality in broad and clear terms (Matt. 15:19-20; Mark 7:20-23).
Disputes about Bible interpretation
What did Satan say in the garden to Eve?
"Did God really say?"
However, horrible experiences in the church community make these mis-interpretations easy to believe.
People are looking for another alternative
But we can level the playing field by looking at those in this lifestyle not as a special category of sin (which it is not) but say that we all sin.
The ground is level at the cross.
We need to always remember that what God said is GOOD.
Do I really believe that taking up my cross and following Jesus will be good for me, better that indulging in my sinful sexual passions.
Common Objections (when face-to-face)
A Modest Goal
Focus on putting a rock (pebble) in the shoe (build the bridge, not burn it)
Ask a question before giving a statement
Some version of: "What do you mean by...?"
Some version of: "What do you think about...?"
Some version of: "What's your opinion on...?"
Objection #1
This is my Identity
What makes you say that?
What do you mean by "accept"?
What would you say to someone who said the same thing about: pornography use, alcohol addiction, etc.?
What role does the Body play in determining who you are?
Is your sexuality all that you are? Are you more than that?
Remember: Our sexuality is not our identity; it's what we have, but it's not who we are.
Objection #2
Born this way (biological or genetic factor)
American Psychological Association 2008: "No findings have emerged that permit scientists to conclude orientation is determined by any particular factor for factors."
The American Psychiatric Association 2015: "Some people believe that sexual orientation is innate and fixed; however, sexual orientation develops across a person's lifetime."
Scientific American 2019: "Massive Study Finds No Single Genetic Cause for Same-Sex Sexual Behavior."
Consensus: there are multiple factors, but there is no genetic or biological cause for same-sex attraction.
Even if there were it would not matter, because we were born in sin.
Objection #3
Civil Rights
Objection #4
Love is Love / Love has no labels
Why do you care?
An emotional response
A test showing two people on a screen...
What would be the response if the couple are a 50 year-old man with a 15 year-old boy? Or more than two people? Or a 60 year-old woman and a 15 year-old girl?
But this is now coming
Headline from 2021 issue of The New Yorker
"How Polyamorists and Polygamists are Challenging Family Norms"
Albert Mohler, The Briefing Oct. 22, 2026
"Now comes the push for Polyamory" - meaning multiple loves.
As opposed to Polygamy, which means many spouses.
But in the end there is little difference.
This is not the same behavior, but it follows the same logic.
Our culture says that freedom is everything
True freedom is restrictions rightly placed
People outside of God's design do not flourish
Objection #5: "Gay relationships don't hurt anyone."
Have you ever talked to the kids of gay parents?
Katy Faust & Stacy Manning - Them Before Us
We have talked to a teacher who has had to teach a 3rd grade boy being raised by two dads
The boy's behavior reflected a home-life that exposed him to things no child should experience, leading him to act out in class.
Heather Barwick (former gay-marriage advocate)
"I grew up surrounded by women who said they didn't need or want a man. Yet, as a little girl, I so desperately wanted a daddy. It is a strange and confusing thing to walk around with this deep-down unquenchable ache for a father, for a man, in a community that says that men are unnecessary. There were time I felt so angry with my dad for not being there for me, and then times I felt angry with myself for even wanting a father to begin with."
While a mother and father are not sufficient for the flourishing of the child they are an incredibly important piece, you could argue a necessary piece, for the child to experience what God intends for them.
Social science literature shows that many individuals who have sexuality and gender confusion are often downstream from brokenness in the home at some level.
Mother important, studies show father is more important.
Objection #6: Hatred, Bigotry, and Homophobia
Time for another rock in the shoe
What makes you say that? What do you mean by 'hate'? What is your story?
Have you had bad experiences with Christians in the past? Can you tell me about that? What was it like? Help me understand?
Are you open to the idea that I might really love and care about you, even if I disagree with you?
Culture tells them that to disagree is the hate them.
If we love people well we leave a home for God's grace
Aside from affirming your sexuality, how could I express my love for you?
we do not affirm all the choices of our kids, but we still love them
Objection #7: You are denying me happiness and fulfillment
I am just going to be alone for the rest of my life?
Huffington Post essay - Together Alone
"Marriage equality and the changes in legal status were an improvement for some gay men. But for a lot of other people, it was a letdown. Like, we have this legal status, and yet there's still something unfulfilled."
The reality of loneliness in the gay community
Note: same-sex marriage does not fill this loneliness that only God can!
As a church we can guide them to God
Rock in the shoe
What do you think about the stories of people who are married, yet still feel like something is missing?
Have you ever read what Jesus says about surrendering your life to Him?
If God created your heart, do you think that He knows how to fill it?
Samaritan woman - crossed all social boundaries
John 4:13-14
Marriage is not the source of our fulfillment, only Jesus alone is
Becket Cook - Change of Affection
"Surrendering my sexuality hasn't been easy. I still struggle with vestiges of same-sex attraction, but denying myself, taking up my cross, and following Jesus is an honor. Any struggles I experience pale in comparison to the joy of a personal relationship with the one who created me and give my life meaning. My identity is no longer in my sexuality; it's in Jesus."
Reminder: The solution to our sexual brokenness is not shame or indulgence; it's surrender.
Basic Discipleship
Focus on Christ (as opposed to too much focus on their sin)
Focus on Relationships (build healthy churches and communities in the church that are loving)
This will replace that gay community where they had found acceptance
Focus on the Family
Downstream from brokenness. need discipleship in a family environment
Focus on the Men
Men have such a significant and influential role as leaders of their households and leaders of the church.
Social science affirms that while the mother's role in the family is significant, the father's role is even more powerful.
The degree to which a father has a relationship that is involved and present and nurturing of their son or their daughter is a direct correlation to how they end up later in life.
Less anxiety
less depression
less behavioral problems
being more well-adjusted in their gender and sexual identity
Rules without relationships will lead to rebellion
Romans 1:16
"For I am not ashamed of the gospel, because it is the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes, first to the Jew, and also to the Greek."
Session IV: Practical Application//Gender + Sexuality & The Church
When we step out into the world, we encounter sexual brokenness.
We know what God's Word says
But how do we truly minister to people trapped
How do we skillfully take what God's Word says and apply it to the lives of the people whom God has entrusted to our care? How do we minister well to people?
Precepts, Principles and Practices (leave in notes, but do not use in presentation)
1 Cor. - eating meat questions that Paul dealt with
Will this violate a clear command of God?
1 Cor. 10:14-18, 19-21
There are some things that are incompatible with the worship of God
We will face increasing pressure to erase the clear boundaries that God has drawn around this sexual behavior
as Paul says, we cannot
Am I dealing with a Christian or a non-Christian?
1 Cor. 5:9-13
Inside vs outside (Christian or non)
If inside, you cannot abide these behaviors by confronting them (Matt. 18)
Those outside we cannot expect them to live as Christian, but we need to develop a relationship and need the gospel. They need Christ.
If a non-Christian
Will this hinder them from coming to faith in Christ?
1 Cor. 10:24-27
We cannot erase the lines God has drawn
If a Christian
Will this hinder them from growing in Christ?
1 Cor. 10:28-30; 8:10-13
You may lead him astray so refrain
Precept vs Principle
Precept - School zone speed limit
Ex. 20:3; 1 Cor. 10:14
Principle - "Please drive carefully - children at play"
1 Cor. 10:24,31
What do we do with the following situations?
Gender pronouns
What is objectively true about the person?
Their biological sex/gender (Gen. 1:27)
Satan is liar (John 8:44)
Truth brings Freedom (John 8:32)
Truth telling (Eph 4:25)
How emotionally significant for them?
Ask: "How important is this to you?"
Ask: "How upset will you be if I feel uncomfortable calling you by ________?"
Ask: "What I hear you saying is: you want me to honor what you believe about yourself - is that correct?"
Ask: "I want to honor you, but I also want to honor what I believe. So, how do we decide?"
Suggest: "Shouldn't we go with what's objectively true instead of what we deeply feel?"
If you feel comfortable: Maybe suggest calling them by their preferred name, but not their preferred pronoun.
At the same time: What you feel comfortable with will probably change based upon who the person is to you.
If they refuse: Maybe this is not a battle worth fighting until they're ready to listen to what's true.
Do not wear yourself out trying to convince every single person.
Proverbs 1:29-31
What's at stake?
For them: a slippery slope - it starts with pronouns, but it rarely ends there.
Social transitioning is incredibly powerful - it can reinforce and entrench the new identity. --Abigail Shrier, Irreversible Damage
Can become an endless imitation game and popularity contest
For them: ongoing identity crisis and mental health issues.
For them: ongoing mentality of self-delusion, which hinders their ability to repent and believe the true gospel.
For us: compromise on Biblical truth. Jesus never endorsed a lie for the sake of love or influence (John 15:18-20a).
1 Cor. 13:4-7
Attending a Gay Wedding
Some say "Yes"
Jesus was a friend of sinners (Mark 2:15-16; Luke 7:34; 19:10)
Maintain the relationship - our Christian influence.
Belonging often occurs before believing.
Some say "No" (my stance)
This is not a generic social gathering
Why is a wedding different?
Jesus did hang out with sinners, but He also turned people away with the offense of the gospel (Mark 10:22; John 6:66)
A wedding ceremony is a worship service.
A wedding ceremony is a celebration.
A Christian's presence communicates our endorsement of the relationship (Romans 14:22)
Kevin De Young - article in the Gospel Coalition in 2015
"Quite explicitly, the wedding is not a party for friends and family. It's not a mere ceremonial formality. It is a divine event in which those gathered celebrate and honor the 'solemnization of matrimony.' Which is why - as much as I might want to build bridges with a lesbian friend or reassure a gay family member that I care for him and want to have a relationship with him - I would not attend a same-sex wedding ceremony. I cannot help with my cake, with my flowers, or with my presence to solemnize what is not holy."
The "How" matters just as much as the "What"
Is there a way to decline, but intentionally invite an ongoing relationship?
Is there some way to accept without violating your conscience or sending the wrong message?
We must clearly communicate our love and concern for our friends and loved ones - regardless of what choice we make (Mark 12:30-31)
We must be willing to lose close relationships as the price of faithfulness (Matt. 19:28-29; Luke 14:26-27; John 15:18-20)
My Child has come out as _________
Some Ideas
Don't freak out!
This is not an unforgivable sin
Clearly communicate your love for him/her
Thank them for coming to you with this.
Be curious: "What makes you say that? Help me understand... Tell me more..."
Some further ideas
Consider: Social connection vs. Romantic affection.
Clarify: Attraction vs. Sexual attraction.
Culture and social pressure encourages sexual
Counsel: Help them interpret these natural transitions in life.
Challenge: Ask them to explain what they mean by ________
Ministry to Transgender Individuals Course
Q&A